Philaletheis produces acclaimed play “Proof”

Liza Darwin Assistant Arts Editor

How closely tied are genius and madness? David Auburn’s acclaimed play, “Proof,” tackles the close relationship between the two mental states. “Proof” follows the story of Robert, a once-genius mathematician who has supposedly had a mental breakdown. After Robert dies, his daughter Claire returns home to find a notebook containing a new mathematical proof. Claire does not know if the notebook belongs to her father or her mathematically-inclined sister, Catherine, who claims that it contains her work. Claire and her father’s former student Hal set out to discover the mystery of who really wrote the incredible proof, with emotions and relationships complicating matters along the way.

Such a heavy subject matter was an important consideration for Philip Camhi ’07, the director of the Philaletheis production. “‘Proof’ really raises the question that since genius and insanity are both the result of abnormal functioning of the brain, how do we distinguish the two? Why do we treat one as a medical condition and stand in awe of the other? Why is one considered a valid expression of an authentic self and one a mistake to be corrected?” said Camhi.

Camhi appreciated that the play presents challenges about societal assumptions about the link between mental illness, art, and genius, which is one of the reasons he wanted to direct this particular work. Although “Proof” presents relevant and serious questions, the relationships between the characters increases its relevance to modern life. “What makes the play even better is that on top of these questions is a moving, character-driven story that would stand alone as a great piece of theater without any subtext,” said Camhi.

Camhi became involved in “Proof” as a final project for his senior year. After helping with lighting design, acting, and serving on various Philaletheis committees, directing was the one thing Camhi had not yet tried and wanted to attempt. “Since I’m a senior and no one in their right mind would ever let me direct in the real world, this was my last opportunity to try it,” he said.

As a character-driven show, working with the cast to develop characters was Camhi’s biggest challenge. The cast has worked hard to portray the subtleties of mental illness and the complex inter-personal relationships in the show. “I have a really great cast, and despite my lack of experience, working with them has made the process much more manageable and rewarding,” said Camhi.

“Proof” differs from many Vassar productions in that it will be performed outside. The play will take place outdoors in the South Commons, and this new location will make it a unique experience for attendees. “The show will leave you thinking but will also keep you entertained,” commented Camhi. The play will leave audience members “questioning their assumptions if they want to—and if not, it is still a fun play.”
“Proof” will be performed April 27-28 at 8 p.m.